Never by Another Journal Again Article
5 Options to Consider After Article Rejection
In last weeks' blog post, we looked at some of the well-nigh common reasons behind the rejection of manuscripts, but what if y'all're on the receiving end of a rejection? Peer review is about making your paper the best it can perchance be, but if your newspaper has been rejected, knowing this doesn't brand information technology whatsoever easier. However, it'southward very common for papers to be rejected; studies accept shown that around 21% of papers are rejected without review, while approximately 40% of papers are rejected after peer review.
So, what are your options if your manuscript is rejected? If your paper was rejected without review due to information technology falling outside the aims and scopes of the journal, you should detect a new journal to submit to (find tips on choosing the right journal for you lot here). If you receive your rejection afterwards review, you should have some good suggestions well-nigh possible improvements you could make to your paper. Some of the options you might want to consider include:
1. Make the recommended changes and resubmit your manuscript to the same journal.
If you'd like to publish in a particular journal, and the editor has indicated that they volition have your paper if revisions are made, then this is probably your best option. However, if your paper was rejected outright and the editor doesn't want to reconsider, you should respect this decision and submit elsewhere.
ii. Make changes and submit your manuscript to a dissimilar journal.
Commencement, take into account whatever recommendations y'all may have received during the first round of review, and if necessary, piece of work on improving your manuscript earlier submitting it to another periodical. Don't forget to adapt any details such every bit the embrace letter, referencing, and whatsoever other journal specific details before submission to a different journal.
3. Make no changes and submit your manuscript to a different periodical. This is an easy selection, but i that you lot should probably avoid. To brainstorm with, whatever suggestions made during the first circular of review could atomic number 82 to improvements in your paper; not taking these suggestions into account would be missing the opportunity to increase your chance of credence at the next journal. Secondly, in that location is the possibility that your manuscript may exist assessed past the same reviewers at the new periodical (especially if you work inside a niche field). Their recommendation is unlikely to change if you lot haven't addressed any of the concerns raised in the previous review.
4. Discard the manuscript and never resubmit information technology. You might determine that it's non worth the trouble of resubmitting your manuscript, but call up that your work is still valuable. It may be that the data yous have nerveless is useful to someone else, or that your paper could help another researcher avoid generating similar negative results. Yous could consider posting your paper to sites such equally figshare or Dryad, where it volition exist both accessible for others and citable.
5. Appeal the decision. If you feel that the decision to reject was unfair, or there were major flaws in the review process, then as the author you have the right to appeal. Virtually journals will have a publicly described policy for appealing editorial decisions. It's important to remember that, equally much every bit rejection hurts, your decision to entreatment should be based on logic rather than emotion.
Yous should appeal if you believe that any misconduct has taken place, or a legitimate misunderstanding or error that has led to the decision to refuse your work. Brand it clear to the editor why you are appealing the determination and be careful not to use emotive, combative linguistic communication. If your work has been rejected based on the scope of the journal, or its perceived impact, and then appeals are unlikely to exist successful.
What steps have you lot taken subsequently an article rejection? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Image Credit/Source: eternalcreative/Getty Images
Source: https://www.wiley.com/network/researchers/submission-and-navigating-peer-review/5-options-to-consider-after-article-rejection
0 Response to "Never by Another Journal Again Article"
Post a Comment